Jimmy Carter's Mexican Cafe

(12 Ratings)
Local favorite
Traditional style with a little camp makes Jimmy Carter's a great Mexican dining experience without having to travel the extra few miles over the border.


Your support makes our travel guides possible

We believe that LGBTQ+ people deserve safe vacations that allow them to be their authentic selves. That's why our City Guides aren't locked behind a paywall. Can you contribute today?

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated

Reviews

fitandsolid
fitandsolid
Over a year ago

Mexican food with a touch of gay

Much like the Brian's location near Uptown, this restaurant benefits from the cruise factor, which elevates the otherwise standard (but reasonably-priced) Mexican fare. Because Jimmy Carter's is directly across from the uber-gay Park Manor Suites and just a block away from the mature homo dive The Caliph, the presence of gays in this section of Bankers Hill is usually sufficient to cause Grinder to crash. Breakfasts on the mornings after popular bar nights can be as cruisy as evenings (again, like Brian's in Hillcrest).


bobnabq
bobnabq
Over a year ago

Love it !

I've been here numerous times. It's extremely gay friendly. The staff is great, and the food is fantastic. Very reasonable prices.


shawna_lynn
shawna_lynn
Over a year ago

Wonderful Small Restaurant!

I've dinned here twice and both times I was welcomed and made to feel at home. Very Trans/gay friendly, and in a family atmosphere. The prices are good, the portions are BIG! I could only eat half my burito!


DonSanDiegain
DonSanDiegain first review First to Review
Over a year ago

GoodFood

They serve good food, low cost, and great service. Not bad for a small restaurant.


Other Restaurants in Hillcrest

Hash House A Go Go

Huge servings of "twisted farm food"
Hillcrest

Crest Cafe

A modern Cali cafe
Hillcrest

Arrivederci Ristorante

Tasty Italian fare
Hillcrest

Parma Cucina Italiana

Classic dishes with traditional recipes
Hillcrest

Ortega's A Mexican Bistro

Classy Mexican menu
Hillcrest

Snooze, an A.M. Eatery

Seasonal menu and creative cocktails
Hillcrest

Kous Kous Moroccan Bistro

Kick back and kous kous
Hillcrest

Barrel & Board

Chic cahrcuterie
Hillcrest

Gay Bars in Hillcrest

The Loft

Strong drinks, friendly vibes
Hillcrest

The Rail

Diverse dance bar
Hillcrest

Number One Fifth Avenue

Local Hillcrest hangout
Hillcrest

Urban MO's Bar & Grill

Fun in the heart of SD
Hillcrest

Flicks

Since 1983
Hillcrest

Rich's

Hillcrest hot spot
Hillcrest